Official Journal of the Neurootological and Equilibriometric Society
Official Journal of the Brazil Federal District Otorhinolaryngologist Society
The International Tinnitus Journal received 11891 citations as per google scholar report
Review Paper Pages:160-169
Authors: Massimo Ralli, Arianna Di Stadio, Irene Claudia Visconti, Francesca Yoshie Russo, Maria Patrizia Orlando, Maria Paola Balla, Antonio Greco, Marco de Vincentiis
Many symptoms of multiple sclerosis may affect the ear, nose and throat. The most common otolaryngologic symptoms of multiple sclerosis are speech disorders, followed by sleep disorders, vertigo and disequilibrium, dysphagia, smell alterations, and hearing loss. Less common symptoms include sialorrhea, facial palsy, taste alterations, trigeminal neuralgia and tinnitus. The origin of otolaryngologic symptoms in multiple sclerosis is mainly central, although increasing evidence also suggests a peripheral involvement. Otolaryngologic symptoms in multiple sclerosis may have different clinical presentations; they can appear in different stages of the pathology, in some cases they can be the presenting symptoms and their worsening may be correlated with reactivation of the disease. Many of these symptoms significantly affect the quality of life or patients and lead to increased morbidity and mortality. Otolaryngologic symptoms are common in multiple sclerosis; however, they are often overlooked. In many cases, they follow the relapsing-remitting phases of the disease, and may spontaneously disappear, leading to a delay in multiple sclerosis diagnosis. Clinicians should be aware of otolaryngologic symptoms of multiple sclerosis, especially when they are associated to neurologic symptoms, as they may be early signs of a still undiagnosed multiple sclerosis or could help monitor disease progression in already diagnosed patients.
Keywords: otolaryngologic symptoms, demyelination, multiple sclerosis, otolaryngology, MRI
Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is an autoimmune-mediated neurodegenerative demyelinating disease characterized by relapsing and remitting phases with invalidating longterm sequelae especially in late-diagnosed cases . MS is one of the most common neurodegenerative diseases with a prevalence that vary with geography and ethnicity ranging from 2 per 100.000 in Japan to more than 100 per 100.000 in Northern Europe and North America . MS has a strong gender effect, with prevalence in women almost double compared to men .
The etiology and pathogenesis of MS remains unclear [3-5]; it may be correlated to genetic predisposition , to environmental factors and food habits , and to the action of viruses that induce the expression of recessive genotypes . Any of these may induce an altered autoimmune response of the central nervous system that leads to destruction of myelin associated with activated microglia [9,10]. Microglia, a cell population that belongs to the macrophage family, can change its phenotype by passing from an aggressive-demyelinating form (M1) to a protective-demyelinating form (M2) [9,10]. The alternation between these two forms is modulated by several factors  and may explain the temporariness of many MS symptoms and their natural regression. However, besides the presence of microglia at sites of demyelination, its role in the pathogenesis of MS is only beginning to be revealed .
MS clinical presentation and progression are characterized by high variability and diversity . Common symptoms include weakness or numbness in one or more limbs, optic neuritis, tremor and ataxic gait from cerebellar dysfunction, double vision, dysarthria, or dizziness and fatigue . Most symptoms have an acute onset; however, the pattern of presentation can be highly variable, and symptoms may fluctuate considerably or even progress in correlation with the relapsing/remitting phases of the disease [10,12].
Many symptoms of MS may affect the ear, nose and throat. They include hearing loss, tinnitus, vertigo and disequilibrium, facial palsy, dysphonia, dysphagia, sialorrhea, trigeminal neuralgia and neuropathy, sleep disorder and taste and smell alterations. The prevalence of otolaryngologic symptoms in patients with MS may significantly vary; they present in different stages of the pathology (early- or late-MS) and their worsening may be correlated with the reactivation of MS [1,10]. Prevalence of the otolaryngologic symptoms that may present in patients with MS is detailed in Table 1.
|Otolaryngologic symptom||Prevalence in multiple sclerosis|
|Taste alterations||< 5%|
|Trigeminal neuralgia-sensory neuropathy||0.3%-2%|
Table 1. Prevalence of the otolaryngologic symptoms that may present in patients with MS.
The origin of otolaryngologic symptoms in MS is mainly central, although increasing evidence also suggests a peripheral involvement [5,9,13,14]. O’Malley et al. studied the temporal bones of patients with systemic auto-immune diseases and Sensorineural Hearing Loss (SNHL) or vertigo and identified microglia in the inner ear ; however, the specific phenotype was not identified. Other authors have shown that microglia can migrate from the brain to the close neural structures [14,16] following inflammation. It can be therefore speculated that microglia could migrate through the internal auditory canal reaching the cochlea and determining the demyelination of inner ear structures such as hair cells and spiral ganglion . The possible migration of microglia to the periphery may determine not only audio-vestibular symptoms, but also other otolaryngologic symptoms (Figure 1).
Figure 1: The image shows the auditory, facial and vestibular pathways. Lesions in pons, medulla and brainstem located in one or more area of these pathways may generate a symptom. Multiple symptoms can be observed especially in the late stages of multiple sclerosis, due to the dissemination of demyelinating lesions.
Otolaryngologic symptoms, as many others in MS, tend to be transient and regress spontaneously. Most of them, especially when the exact pathogenesis is unclear, are treated during the acute phase with corticosteroids. Steroids, thanks to their combined immune-suppressant/ anti-inflammatory activity, can rapidly resolve the symptoms, but may also lead to a delay in the diagnosis of MS.
The high variability of presentation and different characteristics of otolaryngologic symptoms often lead to a delay in the definite diagnosis of MS. The aim of this review is to describe and discuss current evidences and highlight recent findings of the otolaryngologic symptoms of MS.
Hearing loss and tinnitus
Several studies have documented the relationship between MS and hearing loss and tinnitus [16-20]. Hearing deficits in MS present in the form of sudden, progressive or fluctuating SNHL they may appear in the early stages of the disease, often as presenting symptoms, or during the late stages indicating a disease progression as a result of a progressive involvement of the hearing pathways [17,19,20].
Sudden SNHL is more common in the early stages (within two years from diagnosis), while progressive SNHL in late stages (after five years) [16-20]. Often, hearing loss can fluctuate; this may be related to relapsing/remitting phases that occur during the course of MS or to the use of corticosteroids which are able to fight the systemic inflammation generated by MS. In many cases, even in the presence of lesions in the auditory pathways at Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), there are no clinically evident hearing deficits .
The origin of SNHL in MS can be central or peripheral, following demyelination of central or peripheral audiovestibular pathways that acts as an "on-off" mechanism; some authors have observed patients with hearing deficit and altered electrophysiologic responses indicative of demyelination without evidence of lesions at MRI .
Hearing loss may be a presenting symptom of MS ; however, although its importance as an early symptom of MS has been described by many studies, its significance is largely underestimated. This may be due to its temporary nature and the good response to corticosteroid treatment; in fact, nearly 90% of patients with sudden SNHL are given an initial diagnosis of “idiopathic” sudden SNHL .
Tinnitus, the perception of a sound when no external stimulation is present , is commonly found in patients with hearing loss following presbycusis [24,25], noise exposure [26,27] or other auditory conditions [28,29]; however, it can also be found in patients with a clinically normal hearing, following synaptopathy [30,31], somatic disorders [32-37] and psychological dysfunctions .
Tinnitus has been described in many autoimmune conditions ; in patients with MS it may follow SNHL or derive from central nervous system demyelination, especially in cases in which no auditory alterations are evident [18,40].
Audiological investigations as tonal and speech audiometry, Auditory Brainstem Responses (ABR), and transient (TEOAE) or Distortion Product Otoacoustic Emissions (DPOAE) are crucial to correctly describe and characterize hearing deficits in patients with MS. Often, clinical audiometry is not able to detect deficits in MS patients possibly due to forms of hidden hearing loss [30,31,40], and ABR is necessary . A recent review of the literature that included 47 studies and 1533 patients evaluated, among other tests, the role of ABR in MS patients, showing that it was abnormal in the majority of MS patients during the active phase and remained altered in nearly ¼ of the patients even after complete hearing recovery occurred . ABR has an elevate sensitivity and specificity for the detection of demyelination in the auditory pathways of patients with MS. In fact, the increased latencies in the conduction of the auditory impulse and the absence of wave V can be signs of central alteration . Speech audiometry is particularly important to highlight the difficulty in speech perception-especially in noise  that is common in MS patients following abnormal auditory processing  or cognitive deficit that altered the word recognition ability . In addition, attention and auditory discrimination, which are crucial aspects in binaural perception and in the integration of sounds, can be compromised in MS patient . TEOAE and DPOAE may identify damages in specific areas of the cochlea sustained by a peripheral microglia aggression; however, so far their use has been always associated with ABR in clinical studies  because the evidence on the cochlea involvement in MS is still unclear.
SNHL should be always considered in the differential diagnosis of MS, especially in young subjects without a history of hearing impairment . Otolaryngologists should always consider the possibility that SNHL, especially in its sudden form, may be an early symptom of MS.
Vertigo and Disequilibrium
Vertigo and disequilibrium are common symptoms in MS [46,47]. The origin of vertigo can be peripheral, following the involvement of the cochlea , or–mainly-central, due to demyelinating lesions affecting the vestibular pathways such as the vestibular nuclei . In some cases, it may follow the involvement of both the cochlea and the vestibular pathways. The origin of vertigo and disequilibrium in MS patients is more often attributed to stiffness, musculoskeletal weakness and ocular diseases rather than to the involvement of the vestibular pathways and of the inner ear [47,49].
The electrophysiologic investigation with Vestibular Evoked Myogenic Potential (VEMP) has been recently proposed to identify areas of demyelination in the vestibular pathways of MS patients . Furthermore, cervical-VEMPs can exclude the ocular involvement that may modify the sensitivity of VEMPs by interfering with the vestibular responses through ocular fixation compensation by allowing identification of the specific areas affected from demyelination .
The study of nystagmus with Frenzel goggles allows the identification of nystagmus characteristics as direction, latency, adaptation and fatigue. Patients with MS typically present a multidirectional nystagmus without latency ; this may contribute to differential diagnosis by excluding other condition such as vestibular neuritis, Ménière Disease and benign positional paroxysmal vertigo [48,53,54]. Electronystagmography can be used in differential diagnosis to correctly identify which area (brain, pons, medulla o cerebellum) is affected from the demyelination.
Facial palsy may be found in MS patients , sometimes as a presenting symptom [56,57]. Facial palsy may follow a lesion in the central facial pathways, including the motor cortex or the facial nuclei  or be due to a peripheral involvement of the facial nerve following a progressive demyelization of the peripheral axon .
In both cases, a facial palsy with the typical characteristic of a peripheral facial paralysis may be the onset symptom of MS [30-32]. Usually, facial palsy may involve all muscle of the hemiface similar to a Bell’s palsy [58,59] by meaning that the demyelinating lesions are distributed in both brain hemisphere and in particular in the area of motor cortex with involvement of posterior limb of internal capsule and the corticobulbar tract (Figure 2) .
In case of peripheral involvement of the facial pathways, the lesion is commonly located in the Roof Entry Zone , consistently with the theory of microglia migration .
Differential diagnosis with MS in cases of facial palsy is of paramount importance to avoid a delay in MS diagnosis. Due to the rarity of the peripheral involvement (facial nerve outside the stylomastoid foramen), an Electromyography may be not useful for a correct diagnosing a MS-related facial palsy. MS should be considered when there’s no improvement after corticosteroid therapy or in case of short term recurrence; in these cases second-level investigations such as MRI to identify the demyelinating lesions should be performed [61,62].
Trigeminal Neuralgia and Trigeminal Sensory Neuropathy
Maxillofacial manifestations such as trigeminal neuralgia and trigeminal sensory neuropathy have been reported in MS .
Trigeminal neuralgia has been reported in MS with prevalence near 2% of cases ; it usually appears after the diagnosis of MS has been made although it can be the first manifestation of the disease in 0.3% of cases . Trigeminal neuralgia in MS is characterized by paroxysmal severe pain that only lasts for a few seconds; however, it can return multiple times during the day . Curiously, Hartman et al. observed that in MS the trigeminal neuralgia may be triggered by an auditory stimulus .
Sensory neuropathy in MS is often bilateral, progressive and irreversible, with a sudden and often painful onset. It mainly affects the second and third divisions of the trigeminal nerve . Neuropathy of the mental nerve causes numbness of the lower lip and chin, with or without pain .
The origin of trigeminal symptoms in MS is commonly a central lesion in the trigeminal nuclei or in the more superior trigeminal pathway ; Nakashima et al. showed that women affected from MS and trigeminal disorders presented demyelinating lesions in the linear pontine trigeminal root .
The trigeminal nerve function can be investigated using electrophysiologic tests ; the most common finding in MS is the presence of electrophysiologic impairment with increased amplitudes and delayed latencies.
Trigeminal neuralgia in MS may be treated pharmacologically; botulin toxin injection may be helpful to alleviate pain. Surgery should be avoided because it does not offer long term relief (<2 years) in patients with MS .
Smell alterations may be present in MS with a prevalence ranging from 15% to 45% [74-79] and are mainly described during the active phases of the disease. Olfactory disorders in MS often begins with an altered perception of smell (dysosmia) that progressively worsen to complete anosmia [80,81].
The causes of smell alterations in MS can be both peripheral and central demyelination; in the former case, they may be correlated to the damage of the olfactory receptors, while in the latter demyelination plaques that develop in the olfactory bulb or in the cortex–especially the inferior frontal and temporal-lobe regions-may be responsible of the symptoms. In particular, the smell threshold alteration is often associated with a peripheral damage, while odor discrimination is related to a central process [75,77,78,82,83].
The diagnosis of olfactory alterations can be made using olfactometry , and a worsening of this condition may be an indicator of disease progression due to the increasing of number of lesion or to the extension of demyelinating areas [74,79].
Taste alterations have been reported in nearly 20% of MS patients [75,80], although much controversy still exist on the exact prevalence of this symptom due to its strict correlation with smell [80,85]. Taste alterations may appear as presenting symptoms or later in the progression of the disease, and often have a temporary nature associated to the inflammatory phases of MS. Current evidence suggest a central origin of these alterations [85,86]; in particular, transitory taste alterations may follow demyelination in the lateral part of midpontine tegmentum, while in case of a persistent symptom, the demyelinating lesions may occupy midbrain or the caudal portion. Clinical evaluation of taste alterations can be done using electrogustometry, chemogustometry and self-administered questionnaires . Electrogustometry may be very useful for diagnosis and monitoring of MS; Sarmiento et al. showed that patients with MS presented increased threshold and difficulties to identify tastants for all four classic taste qualities on both anterior (VII) and posterior regions of the tongue (IX)  and that such difficulties increased with the progression of MS.
Sialorrhoea and drooling are conditions of hypersalivation  that may be found in many neurodegenerative disorders ; in MS they are usually found in the advanced stages of the disease. Sialorrhea is an invalidating condition with serious implications on quality of life . It can be a primary dysfunction of cholinergic signals, characterized by a hyper production of saliva from the major salivary glands, or it could follow an impairment of swallowing coordination .
Both conditions may be related to a central lesion in the superior salivary nuclei for primary forms and in the swallowing pathways for secondary forms. In case of advanced MS stage, multiple lesions and the spread of demyelination plaques in the brain and medulla may explain the presence of sialorrhea
Sialorrhea may be treated with botulin toxin injected in the salivary glands to reduce the salivary production [90,92-94], with drugs that inhibit saliva production  or with physical rehabilitation to improve the swallowing coordination .
Abnormalities of swallowing are commonly encountered in MS, especially in the most disabled patients ; dysphagia is a symptom that can be found in 20 to 30% of these patients[[97,98]. Dysphagia is characterized by the alteration in the progression of the bolus through oropharynx, hypopharynx and esophagus due to a loss of swallowing coordination[; muscle stiffness or weakness, difficulties in concentration and expiratory/ inspiratory discoordination may further aggravate the symptom . Dysphagia can rarely be a presenting symptom of MS, while it is more often seen in the late stage of the disease. This may follow the increased number of lesions in the swallowing pathways that impact the esophageal phase (upper oesophageal sphincter dysfunction), the increased stiffness of the tongue (buccal phase), and the worsening of weakness of the mouth and neck muscles (pharyngeal-laringeal phase) that alter the swallowing progression [96-99].
Videofluoroscopy studies showed that MS patients present swallowing abnormalities such as dysmotility and impaired retraction of the tongue, delay, prolongation or even loss of the pharyngeal phase, upper esophageal sphincter dysfunction, deficit of laryngeal closure, and diminished laryngeal or pharyngeal sensitivity [100,101].
Dysphagia is an important cause of dehydration and malnutrition in MS patients leading to a high mortality rate .
Swallowing alterations in MS patients can be evaluated through patient’s history, bedside screening examination, fiberoptic endoscopic evaluation of swallowing to evaluate the buccal and pharyngo-laryngeal phases and video-fluoroscopy . Self-administered questionnaires, such as the DYMUS (Dysphagia in Multiple Sclerosis) questionnaire, have also been proposed to evaluate symptom progression .
Electromyography should be performed before treatment to identify the affected muscles and better address treatment with botulin toxin alone  or associated with physical rehabilitation . Alfonsi et al. showed that 92% of patients in the later stage of MS presented prolonged electromyographic activity of suprahyoid/ submental muscle (buccal phase) and an increased time in the laryngo-pharyngeal phase , suggesting to add electromyography to the diagnostic exams to define treatment.
Nearly 40% of subjects with a diagnosis of MS have speech disorders such as dysphonia and dysarthria and, at a lesser extent, comprehension disorders [105,106].
Dysphonia in MS may follow alteration of the vocal fold control and in voice production ; symptoms include hoarseness and poor control of volume and pitch . Transitory spasms of vocal fold may induce sudden and temporary interruptions of voice . Dysarthria is predominantly a mixed form with ataxic and spastic speech characteristics , typically scanning speech.
Dysphonia is more common in the early stage of MS and in some cases it may be a presenting symptom of MS ; it may appear as a transitory hypofunctional dysphonia that recovery spontaneously after 15-20 days , or as an episode of spastic dysphonia without evidence of laryngeal pharyngeal reflux [109,111]. Dysarthria is more common during the late stage of MS.
Both dysphonia and dysarthria may be correlated to an alteration of the expiratory and phonatory times . Nordio et al. showed that a reduction of the expiratory and phonatory time in patients with MS was directly correlated with the increase of the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) score , reporting more speech difficulties during the relapsing phases of MS and suggesting that they may be correlated to the severity of the speech disorder [109,112].
Speech disorders are mainly correlated to demyelinating lesions in the central speech pathways rather than to a peripheral involvement of recurrent nerve ; in particular, these disorders may be observed in case of lesions located in the subthalamic regions  and in the periaqueductal area . They mainly follow a progressive weakness of the musculature that can involve all the speech mechanisms and provoke a relevant decrease of verbal communication skills. The “fatigue” component is extremely relevant in the expiration mechanism and the stiffness that affects muscle involved in speech production and emission may further worsen speech .
Speech disorders in patient with MS may be investigated with perceptual, acoustic, aerodynamic, and physiological assessments though computer or laboratory-based practices . Specifically, voice characteristic can be evaluated with the Multi-Dimensional Voice Program (MDVP) , electroglottography  and videostroboscopy . These methods can measure phonation instability , alterations of voice parameters in specific frequency bands, jitter, and shimmer  by offering a detailed investigation of voice features .
Many studies have revealed that an early treatment of MS and a speech rehabilitation therapy in MS patients with speech disorders can significantly help in controlling the progressive alteration in the intelligibility of the speech capacity [120-122].
Sleep Disorders (SD), including Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA) and Central Sleep Apnea (CSA), are significantly underestimated comorbidities in patients with MS  with a significant worsening of quality of life . SD may worsen fatigue, common in patients with MS [125,126]; however, the extent to which OSA and CSA contribute to these symptoms remains unclear [127,128].
There may be significant bidirectional relationships between SD and MS. Previous studies have demonstrated that the prevalence and severity of SD are higher in persons with MS [129,130]. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that among patients with MS, OSA and SD are significantly associated with diminished visual memory, verbal memory, executive function, attention, processing speed, and working memory .
The lesions involving the brainstem and the spinal cord could alter breathing control and upper airway muscle activity. The physiological respiration rate and synchronism during the night comprehends an increase of the pharyngeal tone; the tone is strongly hold due to the coordination between the palatal and genioglossus muscles and the action of the X and XII cranial nerves [132,133]. In some MS patients, lesions can alter the equilibrium of afferent nerves and chemoreceptors, resulting in OSA. Simultaneously, intermittent hypoxia could increase oxidative stress and, combined with alterations in hypocapnia sensitivity thresholds, may worsen neurodegeneration in patients with MS, leading to CSA [134,135]. The main cause lies on alterations in the brainstem, which often occur in the late stage of the disease . Braley et al. evaluated apnea-hypopnea and central apnea indices in 48 patients with MS compared to 48 controls showing significantly worse results among MS patients, and suggesting a predisposition for OSA and CSA among patients with MS, particularly among those with brainstem involvement .
Diagnosis and assessment of SD can be done using polysomnography . Continuous positive airway pressure has been shown to play a significant role in OSA and especially-CSA in MS patients .
Otolaryngologic symptoms are common in MS; however, they are often overlooked. They can appear either during the early stage of the disease, in some cases being the presenting symptoms of MS, or at a later stage. Sometimes they can even precede the evidence of the lesions at the MRI, as reported for sudden SNHL and facial palsy. Many of these symptoms significantly affect the quality of life or patients and lead to increased morbidity and mortality.
In many cases, otolaryngologic symptoms follow the relapsing-remitting phases of the disease, and may spontaneously disappear, leading to a delay in MS diagnosis when the condition is still undiagnosed. Furthermore, the common use of corticosteroids to treat these symptoms regardless their origin often results in a regression or resolution of the symptom; however, this may also delay the diagnosis of MS.
It would be recommended for clinicians involved with the diagnosis and therapy of these symptoms to also consider MS as a possible cause, especially when associated to neurologic symptoms, as they may provide further clinical suspect of a central condition. Furthermore, a better knowledge of the otolaryngologic symptoms of MS is auspicial among otolaryngologists, audiologists and phoniatricians as this could help considering MS as an etiologic factor in these patients. Last, neurologists should consider the role of the otolaryngologist in the clinical management of patients with MS to help identifying symptoms indicative of disease progression.
1Department of Sense Organs, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy
2Department of Otolaryngology, University of Perugia, Italy
3Department of Odontostomatology and Maxillofacial Sciences, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy
4Department of Anatomy, Histology, Legal Medicine and Orthopaedics, Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
Send correspondence to:
Arianna Di Stadio
Department of Otolaryngology, University of Perugia, Perugia, Italy. E-mail: email@example.com
Citation: Ralli M, Stadio AD, Visconti IC, Russo FY, Orlando MP, Balla MP, Greco A, De Vincentiis M. Otolaryngologic Symptoms in Multiple Sclerosis: A Review. Int Tinnitus J. 2018;22(2): 143-149.